7616 7974 dec15
October 19, 2014 | 12:00am
Though his new collection of essays, “The Undocumented
Mark Steyn: Don’t Say You Weren’t Warned” (Regnery), recounts many of
the biggest political events of recent history, bestselling author Steyn
says that’s not the real battleground. While everyone is focused on the
2014 midterms, the question about where our country is headed is being
decided in our entertainment and our schools. Here, in an excerpt from
the book, he explains how culture is king.
Over the past few decades, I’ve seen enough
next-presidents-of-the-United-States for several lifetimes: Phil Gramm,
Pete Wilson, Bob Dornan, Bob Dole, Elizabeth Dole, Orrin Hatch, Gary
Bauer, Lamar Alexander, Tom Tancredo, Tommy Thompson, Alan Keyes. . . .
“The Undocumented Mark Steyn: Don’t Say You Weren’t Warned” by Mark Steyn (Regnery)
Would it have made any difference to the country had any of these
fine upstanding fellows prevailed? Or would we be pretty much where we
are anyway? Aside from a trade agreement here, a federal regulation
there, I’d plump for the latter.
You can’t have conservative government in a liberal culture, and that’s the position the Republican Party is in.
After the last election, I said that the billion dollars spent by the
Romney campaign on robocalls and TV ads and all the rest had been
entirely wasted, and the Electoral College breakdown would have been
pretty much what it was if they’d just tossed the dough into the Potomac
and let it float out to sea.
But imagine the use all that money and
time could have been put to out there in the wider world.
Liberals expend tremendous effort changing the culture. Conservatives
expend tremendous effort changing elected officials every other
November — and then are surprised that it doesn’t make much difference.
Culture trumps politics — which is why, once the question’s been
settled culturally, conservatives are reduced to playing catch-up,
twisting themselves into pretzels to explain why gay marriage is really
conservative after all, or why 30 million unskilled immigrants with a
majority of births out of wedlock are “natural allies” of the Republican
Party.
Steyn argues that, like politics, the Supreme Court is also playing catch-up to culture.Photo: Getty Images
We’re told that the presidency is important because the head guy gets
to appoint, if he’s lucky, a couple of Supreme Court judges. But
they’re playing catch-up to the culture, too.
In 1986, in a concurrence to a majority opinion, the chief justice of
the United States declared that “there is no such thing as a
fundamental right to commit homosexual sodomy.” A blink of an eye, and
his successors are discovering fundamental rights to commit homosexual
marriage.
What happened in between? Jurisprudentially, nothing: Everything
Chief Justice Warren Burger said back in the ’80s — about Common Law,
Blackstone’s “crime against nature,” “the legislative authority of the
State” — still applies. Except it doesn’t. Because the culture — from
school guidance counselors to sitcom characters to Oscar hosts — moved
on, and so even America’s Regency of Jurists was obliged to get with the
beat.
Because to say today what the chief justice of the United States said
28 years ago would be to render oneself unfit for public office — not
merely as Chief Justice but as CEO of a private company, or host of a
cable home-remodeling show, or dog-catcher in Dead Moose Junction.
What politician of left or right championed gay marriage? Bill
Clinton? No, he signed the now notoriously “homophobic” Defense of
Marriage Act. Barack Obama? Gay-wise, he took longer to come out than
Ricky Martin. The only major politician to elbow his way to the front of
the gay bandwagon was Britain’s David Cameron, who used same-sex
marriage as a Sister-Souljah-on-steroids moment to signal to London’s
chattering classes that, notwithstanding his membership of the
unfortunately named “Conservative Party,” on everything that mattered he
was one of them.
If the culture’s liberal, if the schools are
liberal, if the churches are liberal…electing a guy with an ‘R’ after
his name isn’t going to make a lot of difference.
But, in Britain as in America, the political class was simply playing
catch-up to the culture. Even in the squishiest Continental “social
democracy,” once every four or five years you can persuade the
electorate to go out and vote for a conservative party.
But if you want
them to vote for conservative government you have to do the hard work of
shifting the culture every day, seven days a week, in the
four-and-a-half years between elections.
If the culture’s liberal, if the schools are liberal, if the churches
are liberal, if the hip, groovy business elite is liberal, if the guys
who make the movies and the pop songs are liberal, then electing a guy
with an “R” after his name isn’t going to make a lot of difference.
Nor should it. In free societies, politics is the art of the
possible. In the 729 days between elections, the left is very good at
making its causes so possible that in American politics almost anything
of consequence is now impossible, from enforcing immigration law to
controlling spending.
What will we be playing catch-up to in another 28 years? Not so long
ago, I might have suggested transsexual rights. But, barely pausing to
celebrate their victory on gay marriage, the identity-group enforcers
have gone full steam ahead on transgender issues. Once upon a time there
were but two sexes.
Now Facebook offers its 1.2 billion patrons the
opportunity to select their preference from dozens of “genders”: “male”
and “female” are still on the drop-down menu, just about, but lost amid
fifty shades of gay — “androgynous,” “bi-gender,” “intersex,”
“cisfemale,” “trans*man,” “gender fluid” . . .
Oh, you can laugh. But none of the people who matter in American culture are laughing. They take it all perfectly seriously.
Supreme Intergalactic Arbiter Anthony Kennedy wields more power over
Americans than George III did, but in a year or three he’ll be playing
catch-up and striking down laws because of their “improper animus” and
wish to “demean” and “humiliate” persons of gender fluidity.
Having done an impressive job of demolishing the basic societal
building block of the family, the ambitious liberal is now moving on to
demolishing the basic biological building block of the sexes.
Indeed, taken in tandem with the ever greater dominance of women at
America’s least worst colleges and, at the other end of the social
scale, the bleak, dispiriting permanence of the “he-cession,” in 28
years’ time we may be fairly well advanced toward the de facto abolition
of man, at least in the manly sense.
That seems to me at least as interesting a question as whether the
Republicans can take the Senate with a pick-up in this or that swing
state.
Steyn
believes that “the nationalization of the family” can turn a free
western society into a “futuristic dystopia where technology has
advanced but liberty has retreated.”Photo: Getty stock Images
Culture is the long view; politics is the here and now.
Yet in America vast cultural changes occur in nothing flat, while,
under our sclerotic political institutions, men elected to two-year
terms of office announce ambitious plans to balance the budget a decade
after their terms end. Here, again, liberals show a greater
understanding of where the action is.
So, if the most hawkish of GOP deficit hawks has no plans to trim
spending until well in the 2020s, why not look at what kind of country
you’ll be budgeting for by then? What will American obesity and
heart-disease and childhood-diabetes rates be by then? What about rural
heroin and meth addiction?
How much of the country will, with or without
“comprehensive immigration reform,” be socioeconomically
Latin-American? And what is the likelihood of such a nation voting for
small-government conservatism?
There’s a useful umbrella for most of the above: The most
consequential act of state ownership in the 20th century western world
was not the nationalization of airlines or the nationalization of
railways or the nationalization of health care, but the nationalization
of the family.
I owe that phrase to Professor R Vaidyanathan at the Indian Institute
of Management in Bangalore. He’s a bit of a chippy post-imperialist,
and he’s nobody’s idea of a right-winger, but he’s absolutely right
about this.
‘The West has
nationalized families over the last 60 years….Old age, ill health,
single motherhood — everything is the responsibility of the state.’
- Professor R Vaidyanathan
It’s the defining fact about the decline of the West: Once upon a
time, in Canada, Britain, Europe and beyond, ambitious leftists
nationalized industries — steel, coal, planes, cars, banks — but it was
such a self-evident disaster that it’s been more or less abandoned, at
least by those who wish to remain electorally viable.
On the other hand, the nationalization of the family proceeds apace,
and America is as well advanced on that path as anywhere else. “The West
has nationalized families over the last 60 years,” writes Vaidyanathan.
“Old age, ill health, single motherhood — everything is the
responsibility of the state.”
When I was a kid and watched sci-fi movies set in a futuristic
dystopia where individuals are mere chattels of an unseen all-powerful
government and enduring human relationships are banned and the progeny
of transient sexual encounters are the property of the state, I always
found the caper less interesting than the unseen backstory: How did they
get there from here? From free western societies to a bunch of
glassy-eyed drones wandering around in identikit variety-show catsuits
in a land where technology has advanced but liberty has retreated: How’d
that happen?
I’d say “the nationalization of the family” is how it happens. That’s how you get there from here.
Mark Steyn on . . . .
More insights from his new collection, “The Undocumented Mark Steyn.”
. . . ISIS
The roots of ISIS do not lie in the actions America took in 2003. Bush
made mistakes in Iraq and left a ramshackle state that functioned less
badly than any of its neighbors. Obama walked away, pulled out a
cigarette, tossed a match over his shoulder and ignited a fuse that,
from Damascus to Baghdad to Amman and beyond, will blow up the entire
Middle East.
. . . [Obama’s] contempt for American power — a basic class signifier in
the circle in which he’s moved all his life — is so deeply ingrained
that he doesn’t care what replaces it.
. . . Multiculturalism
Just in case you’re having difficulty keeping up with all these
Composite-Americans, George Zimmerman, the son of a Peruvian mestiza, is
the embodiment of epidemic white racism and the reincarnation of Bull
Connor, but Elizabeth Warren, the great-great-great-granddaughter of
someone who might possibly have been listed as a Cherokee on an
application for a marriage license, is a heartwarming testimony to how
minorities are shattering the glass ceiling in Harvard Yard. Under the
Third Reich’s Nuremberg Laws, Mrs. Warren would have been classified as
Aryan and Mr. Zimmerman as non-Aryan. Now it’s the other way round.
Progress!
. . . Big government
Whenever I write about the corrosive effects of Big Government upon the
citizenry in Britain, Canada, Europe and elsewhere, and note that this
republic is fairly well advanced upon the same grim trajectory, I get a
fair few letters on the lines of: “You still don’t get it, Steyn.
Americans aren’t Euro-pansies. Or Canadians. We’re not gonna take it.”
I would like to believe it. It’s certainly the case that Americans have
more attitude than anybody else — or, at any rate, attitudinal slogans. I
saw a fellow in a “Don’t Tread on Me” T-shirt the other day.
He was at
La Guardia, being trod all over by the overgropinfuhrers of the TSA, who
had decided to subject him to one of their enhanced pat-downs. There
are few sights more dismal than that of a law-abiding citizen having his
genitalia pawed by state commissars, but having them pawed while
wearing a “Don’t Tread on Me” T-shirt is certainly one of them.
. . . Islam
I made the mistake of going to Europe to visit the famous banlieues of
Paris and other continental Muslim neighborhoods. And at that point I
started to get the queasy feeling the bewildered investigator does when
he’s standing in the strange indentation at the edge of town and, just
as he works out it’s a giant left-foot print, he glances up to see
Godzilla’s right foot totalling his Honda Civic.
I began to see that
it’s not really about angry young men in caves in the Hindu Kush; it’s
not even about angry young men in the fast growing Muslim populations of
the West — although that’s certainly part of the seven-eighths of the
iceberg bobbing just below the surface of 9/11.
But the bulk of that
iceberg is the profound and perhaps fatal weakness of the civilization
that built the modern world. We’re witnessing the early stages of what
the United Nations Population Division calls a “global upheaval” that’s
“without parallel in human history.”
Demographically and
psychologically, Europeans have chosen to commit societal suicide, and
their principal heir and beneficiary will be Islam.
. . . The tech economy
So what does every initiative of the Obama era have in common?
ObamaCare, Obamaphones, Social Security disability expansion, 50 million
people on food stamps. . . . The assumption is that mass,
multi-generational dependency is now a permanent feature of life.
A
coastal elite will devise ever smarter and sleaker trinkets, and pretty
much everyone else will be a member of either the dependency class or
the vast bureaucracy that ministers to them.
And, if you’re wondering
why every Big Government program assumes you’re a feeble child, that’s
because a citizenry without “work and purpose” is ultimately
incompatible with liberty.
The elites think a smart society will be
wealthy enough to relieve the masses from the need to work. In reality,
it would be neo-feudal, but with fatter, sicker peasants. It wouldn’t
just be “economic inequality,” but a far more profound kind, and
seething with resentments.